12
OPINION
Mountain View News Saturday, January 23, 2021
MOUNTAIN
VIEWS
NEWS
PUBLISHER/ EDITOR
Susan Henderson
PASADENA CITY
EDITOR
Dean Lee
PRODUCTION
SALES
Patricia Colonello
626-355-2737
626-818-2698
WEBMASTER
John Aveny
DISTRIBUTION
CONTRIBUTORS
Stuart Tolchin
Audrey Swanson
Mary Lou Caldwell
Kevin McGuire
Chris Leclerc
Bob Eklund
Howard Hays
Paul Carpenter
Kim Clymer-Kelley
Christopher Nyerges
Peter Dills
Rich Johnson
Lori Ann Harris
Rev. James Snyder
Katie Hopkins
Deanne Davis
Despina Arouzman
Jeff Brown
Marc Garlett
Keely Toten
Dan Golden
Rebecca Wright
Hail Hamilton
Joan Schmidt
LaQuetta Shamblee
STUART TOLCHIN
IT’S NOT JUST US - IT’S JUSTICE
It’s just another Wednesday and gee I’m glad that
I’m still around. Watching the activities of January
20, 2021 which included the farewell of the maskless
Trump “China” virus deniers (never to be mentioned
again) and the arrival of reality in the presentations of
the Joe Biden/Kamala Harris inauguration. Farewell to
the inglorious past four years. An emphatic farewell to
the previously unimaginable riot directed against our
Democracy presented to us live on television just two
Wednesdays ago. The orderly presentation of the inaugural
activities of today including the participation of
former (hooray for former) Vice President Mike Pence and former majority Leader
Mitch McConnell is a hopeful sign. As President Biden explained in his powerful
speech, “If enough of us can work together there is nothing we can’t accomplish”.
Prior to President Biden’s speech, Vice President Kamala Harris repeated
the oath administered to her by Associate Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor.
This oath repeated by an African/South Asian female presented to her by a Hispanic
female Justice led me to think of another time in the not so distant past. In 1972
I was living in Bakersfield and working as the Director of a Legal Services Program.
Bakersfield was and is a very conservative community represented today by House
Minority Leader and staunch Trump supporter (at least until today) Kevin McCarthy.
To relieve some of my frustration and desirous of associating with potentially
like-minded individuals I drove with a friend up to the City of Fresno where a Shirley
Chisholm for President rally was being conducted. Really this was not so long
ago but it was a very different time. Richard Nixon had been elected President in
1968 along with Vice-President Spiro T. Agnew, the former Republican Governor
of Maryland. There seemed little chance that any Democrat could defeat Nixon
although there was some talk that a fairly unpublicized break-in intended to spy on
the Democratic Party might have some effect upon Nixon’s certain re-election. It
didn’t! Nixon won 49 States.
Prior to the election various Democrats competed for their party’s nomination.
Included within this group was the infamous Alabama Governor George
Wallace whose well-remembered campaign slogan was “Segregation now, Segregation
forever! (If you recall, Wallace was the victim of an assassination attempt during
this campaign which left him paralyzed for life.)
Another candidate was Shirley Chisholm who in 1969 was the first Black
woman elected to the United States Congress. She called for a “bloodless Revolution”.
Chisolm said she ran for the office “in spite of hopeless odds to demonstrate
the sheer will and refusal to accept the status quo”. Well change has come as demonstrated
by the election of Vice President Harris and the presence of Justice Sotomayor.
It’s taken 29 years but it has come and is still coming. Progress and coming
equality was unmistakably demonstrated by the appearance of the inaugural poet
Amanda Gorman. This 22 year old African American Woman from Santa Monica,
no less, completely stole the show. She told the world that a skinny Black girl descendant
from slaves, raised by a single mother, stood for the future. She represents
the promise of this Country explaining that Democracy can never be defeated. She
supported President Biden’s assertion that there are “enough of us” to overcome the
divisiveness now present in this country. Her call for Justice included a demand
for equality and an end to systematic racism which has so damaged this country.
Her use of the word “Justice” brought to mind the old Richard Pryor joke of a
generation ago about what “Justice: meant in terms of African Americans relation
to Police conduct. In terms of arrest “Justice” meant penalties and mistreatment
for “Just Us”. The events of the last years resulting in the deaths of George Floyd,
Briana Taylor, Elijah McClain, Michael Brown, Eric Garner and too many others
demonstrate that Pryor’s characterization of what is meant by Justice is still with
us. Hopefully the election of Kamala Harris, together with the presentation by
Amanda Gorman demonstrate that a better understanding of what “Justice” should
mean is on the way. It is this belief and hope that contributed to the naming of my
granddaughter aspirationally named Justice.
Mountain Views News
has been adjudicated as
a newspaper of General
Circulation for the County
of Los Angeles in Court
Case number GS004724:
for the City of Sierra
Madre; in Court Case
GS005940 and for the
City of Monrovia in Court
Case No. GS006989 and
is published every Saturday
at 80 W. Sierra Madre
Blvd., No. 327, Sierra
Madre, California, 91024.
All contents are copyrighted
and may not be
reproduced without the
express written consent of
the publisher. All rights
reserved. All submissions
to this newspaper become
the property of the Mountain
Views News and may
be published in part or
whole.
Opinions and views expressed
by the writers
printed in this paper do
not necessarily express
the views and opinions
of the publisher or staff
of the Mountain Views
News.
Mountain Views News is
wholly owned by Grace
Lorraine Publications,
and reserves the right to
refuse publication of advertisements
and other
materials submitted for
publication.
Letters to the editor and
correspondence should
be sent to:
Mountain Views News
80 W. Sierra Madre Bl.
#327
Sierra Madre, Ca.
91024
Phone: 626-355-2737
Fax: 626-609-3285
email:
mtnviewsnews@aol.com
A member
of the
California
Newspaper
Publishers
Association
LEFT, RIGHT OR CENTER!
TOM PURCELL
WHAT AMERICA NEEDS IS A
HEARTY LAUGH
RICH MANIERI
SEARCHING FOR UNITY IN
A SEA OF EXCLAMATION
POINTS
America
could use a hearty laugh right now, but laughter doesn’t come
easily because too many Americans have lost their sense of humor.
Humor, says Merriam-Webster, is “the ability to be funny or to be
amused by things that are funny.”
We are at our best when we’re amused. Few things can better reduce
stress or shed light on truth than a good joke.
I can’t think of a better time to revisit what some great minds have said about humor’s
incredible value – to both individuals and well-functioning societies.
“Nonsense wakes up the brain cells. And it helps develop a sense of humor, which is awfully
important in this day and age. Humor has a tremendous place in this sordid world.
It’s more than just a matter of laughing. If you can see things out of whack, then you can
see how things can be in whack.” – Dr. Seuss
These words couldn’t be more pertinent to the wackiness of 2021, when half the country
thinks the other half should be silenced in all public forums.
“If you find it hard to laugh at yourself, I would be happy to do it for you.” – Groucho
Marx
Groucho’s words remind me of something that “Saturday Night Live” founder Lorne Michaels
said about poking fun at politicians. He noted that when the show pokes fun at
Republicans, they find it funny – they don’t take the ribbing as personally as do some with
opposite political points of view.
“Imagination was given to man to compensate him for what he is not; a sense of humor to
console him for what he is.” – Francis Bacon
To be sure, we human beings can be flawed in so many ways – our politicians, who are
supposed to reflect our will, even more so.
As some of our more egocentric politicians make trivial matters into large affairs, don’t
they risk overlooking genuine problems that their constituents are begging them to
address?
Doesn’t a sense of humor – which is one and the same as a sense of humility – offer an
antidote to such self-absorption?
“Common sense and a sense of humor are the same thing, moving at different speeds. A
sense of humor is just common sense, dancing.” – William James
Common sense, which Merriam-Webster describes as “sound and prudent judgment
based on a simple perception of the situation or facts,” is no longer common.
Opinion is what is far too common now – opinion that’s not rooted in much of anything
factual, but in everything emotional.
Opinion and sarcasm are closely related – opinion and self-seriousness are strongly related
– but opinion and humor are not related often enough.
Look, America needs to restore its sense of humor. We need a good belly laugh for our
own health and that of our republic.
“We change physiologically when we laugh,” reports WebMD. “We stretch muscles
throughout our face and body, our pulse and blood pressure go up, and we breathe faster,
sending more oxygen to our tissues.”
What our country needs is no more complicated than this great thought from a common-
sense country singer:
“To succeed in life, you need three things: a wishbone, a backbone and a funny bone.” –
Reba McEntire
Tom Purcell, author of “Misadventures of a 1970’s Childhood,” a humorous memoir available at amazon.
com, is a Pittsburgh Tribune-Review humor columnist and is nationally syndicated exclusively by
Cagle Cartoons Inc. For info on using this column in your publication or website, contact Sales@cagle.
com or call (805) 969-2829. Send comments to Tom at Tom@TomPurcell.com.
An email laced with exclamation points
is never a good sign. At least not if you’re
me.
In my world, exclamation points usually
follow words such as “idiot!” or “communist!”
I take issue with the latter though
the former is certainly up for discussion.
Moreover, when the salutation itself is followed
by an exclamation point, as it was
in a recent email, I know it’s trouble. “Mr.
Manieri!”
Inside voice. I’m right here.
This particular writer went on to make
several assumptions about my intellect,
or lack of. He ended with a call to action.
“Defend your character!”
For context, the writer was responding to
a column I wrote in which I blamed President
Trump for lighting the fuse that led
to the Capitol riots. He went on to ask how
I could do such a thing when it was clear
that members of Antifa and Black Lives
Matter were bused in and were, in fact,
responsible for the insurrection – a claim
without any basis in fact.
My response featured a conspicuous absence
of exclamation points as I encouraged
the writer to keep an eye on his blood
pressure.
I resisted quoting from Proverbs 15:
“Those who are hot-tempered stir up
strife, but those who are slow to anger
calm contention.”
If you watch much television, or any television,
or if you engage in social media,
it’s pretty clear that we tend to punctuate
our discourse with exclamation points.
Perhaps Jerry Springer was actually a visionary.
He understood the marketability
of impoliteness and boorish behavior long
before it went mainstream. (By the way, I
promise never to use the name “Springer”
and the word “visionary” in the same sentence
again.)
Civility has fallen out of fashion. Some say
it’s overrated. How do I know this? I refer
you to a Dec. 2019 piece in the Atlantic
titled, “Civility is Overrated.”
An NPR article in 2019 quotes Lynn
Itagaki, an associate professor at the University
of Missouri, who said, “Civility has
been about making sure that the status
quo, the hierarchy of the status quo at the
moment, which means racial inequality,
gender inequality, class inequality, stays
permanent.”
By this redefinition of civility, it would be
permissible and even encouraged to meet
any injustice, perceived or actual, with an
uncivil response. That’s fine if you happen
to agree on the injustice. For example, if
your candidate loses a presidential election
and you believe the election was
rigged, storming the Capitol might be an
appropriately uncivil response.
Thus, if
you disagree
with
someone
and you’re
convinced
you’re on
the right
side, what’s
the point
of a civil
response? After all, you’re right and he’s
wrong.
Many believe our national discourse fell
apart the moment Donald Trump darkened
the doorway of the Oval Office.
Surely, the former president, with his unhelpful
rhetoric, name-calling and incessant
tweeting contributed to the problem.
But he wasn’t alone.
Our elected representatives in Washington
– Republicans and Democrats – have
been content to play their respective parts
in the Monty Python “Argument Clinic”
sketch.
“Is this the right room for an argument?”
“I told you once.”
“No you haven’t.”
“Yes I have.”
“When?”
“Just now.”
“No you didn’t.”
“Yes I did.”
The main difference, of course, between
the sketch and reality is there’s nothing
even mildly amusing about the real thing.
For what it’s worth, President Biden struck
mostly the right tone in his inauguration
speech.
“I pledge this to you – I will be a president
for all Americans, and I promise you, I will
fight as hard for those who did not support
me as for those who did,” Biden said.
He then signed 15 executive orders undoing
various Trump policies.
Unity is a fine message but no amount of
rhetorical gymnastics will bring people together
unless we’re willing to understand
and listen to those with whom we disagree.
That means acknowledging that not
all of the 75 million Americans who voted
for Donald Trump are racists and that not
everyone who voted for Joe Biden is pushing
a Marxist agenda.
From the president on down, unless we’re
truly committed to making unity a reality,
it won’t happen, no matter how many exclamation
points we use.
Rich Manieri is a Philadelphia-born journalist
and author.
Mountain Views News
Mission Statement
The traditions of
community news-
papers and the
concerns of our readers
are this newspaper’s
top priorities. We
support a prosperous
community of well-
informed citizens. We
hold in high regard the
values of the exceptional
quality of life in our
community, including
the magnificence of
our natural resources.
Integrity will be our guide.
Mountain Views News 80 W Sierra Madre Blvd. No. 327 Sierra Madre, Ca. 91024 Office: 626.355.2737 Fax: 626.609.3285 Email: editor@mtnviewsnews.com Website: www.mtnviewsnews.com
|