
Mountain View News Saturday, November 14, 202622 Mountain View News Saturday, November 14, 202622
MEADOWS ADU
(continued from pg. 1)
Developers subsequentlythreatened to increase the
number of homes from 42 to
50 under Senate Bill 330 and
eliminate certain communitybenefits, including a proposedpublic park.
This left Sierra Madre residents
facing a difficult choice.
Measure M appeared on theMay 2023 special election
ballot. A “yes” vote would haveupheld the original 42-homeproject, while a “no” vote
would have risked a denser
development with fewer publicbenefits. Voters approvedMeasure M.
Some residents’ wildfire
concerns materialized in
January 2025 when the
Eaton Fire swept through the
Mater Dolorosa property andadjacent Bailey Canyon area.
Flames threatened homes
downhill from the monastery,
including those on SunnysideAvenue, Sierra Keys Drive,
Sierra Meadow Drive, and OakCrest Drive.
The 17.3-acre lower parceldesignated for The Meadowsremained undevelopedduring the fire. Constructionsubsequently moved forward
after the Planning Commissionapproved Design Review
Permit 25-02 in January 2026.
Toll Brothers acquired theproperty from New UrbanWest in November 2025 and
assumed responsibility for
constructing the 42 homes.
That history set the stagefor the November 10, 2026,
Council meeting.
Developer’s Proposal RaisesQuestions
Before a crowded assemblyof concerned residents, CityCouncil considered two related
resolutions.
Resolution No. 26-104
proposed a Public Benefit
Agreement that would
provide Sierra Madre with$380,160 in financial benefits
and additional housingrestrictions. Resolution No.
26-105 addressed architectural
modifications allowingoptional attached ADUs
within the previously approveddevelopment.
The Meadows encompassesapproximately 17.3 acres nearNorth Sunnyside and WestCarter avenues, including42 detached homes, six
landscaped open-space lots,
and an approximately three-
acre public park.
Wolf explained that
Toll submitted revised
building plans in July 2026incorporating optional ADUs.
City staff initially rejectedthe submission because the
changes exceeded the scopeof the approved design reviewpermit.
However, California law
requires qualifying ADUs
to be approved through aministerial process, generallyleaving cities little discretion toreject compliant applications.
The proposed attached units,
marketed as “Multi-Gen
Suites,” would range from
approximately 270 to 290
square feet and could be
offered to purchasers of all 42homes. Detached ADUs, called
“casitas,” could be offered
on 10 lots along SunnysideAvenue.
Both options would be
voluntary, and the numberof primary residences wouldremain unchanged.
Wolf said the developer’smarket research showed strongdemand for multigenerationalliving arrangements amongprospective buyers.
Council Criticizes Developer’sApproach
Council members questionedwhy Toll introduced the ADUsthrough the routine buildingplan-check process rather thandiscussing the modificationsdirectly with City officials.
Mayor Kristine Lowe
expressed disappointment thatthe cooperative relationshipestablished during negotiationswith New Urban West had not
continued under Toll Brothers.
She emphasized the City’sexpectations for transparency
and cooperation.
Council Member Edward
Garcia and others expressedfrustration that the proposedmodifications appearedinconsistent with the spirit ofthe original agreement. Severalcharacterized the developer’sapproach as a “bait and
switch.”
Deputy City Attorney Julia A.
Homaechevarria clarified that
the original agreement did notinclude ADUs but also did not
explicitly prohibit them. CityManager Michael Bruckner
explained that changes in
California housing laws furtherrestricted the City’s authorityto regulate qualifying ADUs.
Following approximately threeto four months of negotiationswith Toll, City staff developedthe proposed Public BenefitAgreement.
Council members
acknowledged that rejectingthe agreement might not
prevent ADU construction butcould eliminate the financial
benefits and additional
restrictions negotiated with
the developer.
Toll Brothers Defends
Multigenerational Housing
Reichel defended the proposal,
citing demand for livingarrangements accommodatingaging parents, adult children,
caregivers, and extended
families.
“There is incredible buyerdemand for these types of
integrated enhancements toa home that can provide anadditional independent livingsituation for an elderly familymember that will allow them
to still live independentlybut in proximity to family,”
Reichel said.
He emphasized that the units
were primarily intended
as flexible living spacesrather than rental income
opportunities.
The attached suites would
include interior doors
connecting them to the primaryresidences. Reichel argued thatincorporating the units duringinitial construction would
provide greater architecturalconsistency than havinghomeowners build additions
later.
The homes would retain
their approved street-facing
appearances, architectural
styles, and exterior materials.
Although Reichel anticipatedconsiderable buyer interest,
he could not estimate
how many purchaserswould select the options.
Responding to concerns aboutcommunication, Reichel
committed to improving thecompany’s relationship with
City officials and residents.
“We can absolutely commit toproviding weekly updates tothe city on our constructionprogress,” Reichel stated.
“We do know that there have
been concerns, so we have a
neighborhood email address
and we’ve been responding toconcerns from the residents.
[We] absolutely want to be apartner with the city,” he said.
Residents Raise Wildfire
Evacuation Concerns
Public testimony focused
heavily on wildfire safety,
particularly following the
devastating Eaton Fire.
Alexandra Dekansky, a
longtime North SunnysideAvenue resident, questionedwhether the project’s originalenvironmental analysisadequately considered the
population increases that
could result from additional
housing units.
“Now, with the addition ofADUs and casitas, the actual
population could potentially
more than double to 250
residents or more,” Dekanskysaid.
“This represents a substantialincrease in density, traffic,
evacuation demands, and
cumulative environmental
impacts that were not
necessarily contemplated in
the original environmental
impact report.”
The population estimate
represented the resident’s
concern rather than an
established City finding.
Dekansky also recalled herfamily’s experience during theEaton Fire. “I can testify thatthe evacuating and gettingup to safety was terrifying,”
she said. Her family sustained
backyard fire damage and
spent hours using garden hosesto prevent further destruction.
Sharil Fukazaki, whose familyowns property adjacent to thedevelopment, described the
fire’s lasting consequences. “Aportion of our property was
destroyed in the Eaton fire andour home is still unhabitable,”
Fukazaki said. “We continue to
live in a hotel, and we have noidea when we’re going to get togo back home.”
Fukazaki described severe
congestion along SunnysideAvenue during the fire,
including spectators enteringthe neighborhood to
photograph the flames. “Isthere any consideration forprioritizing human lives andsafety over financial gain?” sheasked.
She also submitted
neighborhood oppositionmaterials containingsignatures from concerned
residents. Resident Caroline
Brown similarly questioned thewisdom of increasing housingdensity in a high-fire-risk area.
“Here we are. You overload a
community with people thathave to be evacuated during afire,” Brown said.
Brown also requested an
agreement with Los AngelesCounty Public Works
addressing access between TheMeadows and Bailey Canyon.
Resident Deb Sheridan
urged City officials to
prioritize evacuation
planning, infrastructure, andconstruction oversight. “Please
think this through and protectyour citizens,” Sheridan said.
“Getting a bathroom updateand waiving a reimbursementon a water main replacement
agreement is nothingcompared to the danger andhealth risk to your residents.”
Construction Impacts DrawCriticism
Residents also described
ongoing construction-relateddisruptions, including noise,
dust, odors, damaged streets,
and construction vehicles.
Monique Harding, a
Sierra Keys Drive resident,
questioned the condition ofneighborhood infrastructure.
“Where are the sidewalks?
Where are the streets?”
Harding asked. She also
questioned why the developer
was incorporating ADUs
during construction rather
than leaving those decisions tofuture homeowners.
“I feel that this is a bait and
switch,” Harding said.
Glenn Hickman, who identifiedhimself as an experiencedconstruction professional,
criticized the financial terms of
the Public Benefit Agreementand the absence of detailed
plans for the detached casitas.
“The devil’s in the details,”
Hickman said during the firsthearing.
During the second hearing, heemphasized accountability and
documentation. “The record
needs to be clean,” Hickmansaid.
Hickman also questionedthe Carter Avenue water
reimbursement provisions.
Council Negotiates Casita
Restrictions
The lack of detailed
architectural plans for
detached casitas became
a significant issue duringCouncil deliberations.
Although Toll submitted plansfor the attached Multi-Gen
Suites, it had not developedcomparable plans for the
detached units.
Council members soughtadditional protections for
neighboring properties,
particularly along SunnysideAvenue. Reichel confirmed
that Toll intended to construct
casitas smaller than 800
square feet and outside the20-foot setback established
under the project’s Good
Neighbor Plan. The Good
Neighbor Plan incorporatesprivacy, landscaping, and
noise-reduction commitments
intended to protect existinghomes along the development’swestern boundary.
Council members insisted
that the casita restrictions be
incorporated into a writtenagreement rather than relyingon verbal assurances.
Homaechevarria discussed
language that would formalizethe restrictions while
minimizing conflicts with statehousing laws.
Council ultimately settled onprovisions requiring Toll tosubmit casita plans complyingwith the size and setback
limitations, authorizing the
City Attorney to finalize thewording.
Reichel agreed to the
restrictions but declined to
commit to additional financial
penalties if they were exceeded.
Agreement Provides$380,160 in Public Benefits
Under Resolution No. 26-104,
Toll West Coast LLC agreed toprovide two financial benefitsto Sierra Madre.
The developer would
contribute $86,090 toward
Memorial Park restroom
renovations and waive
$294,070 in reimbursements
otherwise due under the
Carter Avenue Water Main
Replacement Agreement.
Together, those provisionsrepresent $380,160 in financialbenefits. The agreementalso establishes affordabilityrestrictions on qualifyingADUs.
Homeowners could use the
units for family members orother permitted residential
purposes. However, units
offered for rent would be
restricted to qualifying verylow-
income households at
affordable rental rates for 55
years.
Wolf estimated that, under
June 2026 income guidelines,
the maximum monthly rentfor a qualifying one-bedroomADU would be $728.75,
subject to annual adjustments.
Short-term rentals would be
prohibited, and ADUs could
not be sold separately fromtheir primary residences.
Homeowners would also
provide annual occupancy andrental information. The deed-
restricted units could helpSierra Madre satisfy its state-
mandated affordable housingobligations.
Wolf noted that these financial
concessions would supplementapproximately $2.1 million
in development impact feesand an estimated $312,000 in
school district fees associated
with the original project.
Environmental Review and
Evacuation Planning
Residents questioned whetherthe additional units should
trigger a new environmentalreview.
City legal counsel explainedthat the modifications
did not require additional
review under the California
Environmental Quality Act.
Qualifying ADU permits aregenerally ministerial approvalsexempt from CEQA review.
Reichel maintained that the
relatively small attached units
were unlikely to producesubstantial populationincreases, particularlybecause some homeowners
might use them as offices
or accommodations for
individual relatives.
However, Council did not
establish a definitive estimate
of potential additional
residents.
Responding to wildfire
concerns, Council members
discussed improvements to
Sierra Madre’s emergencyevacuation procedures.
Officials acknowledgedshortcomings in the City’s
preparedness during the EatonFire and emphasized the need
for comprehensive evacuationplanning and practice.
Discussions included
geographic information
systems technology,
coordination throughthe Verdugo emergencycommunications system, andrestricting incoming traffic
along Sunnyside Avenue
during emergencies.
Although the resolutions didnot directly address evacuationplanning, the discussion
underscored residents’
ongoing concerns about publicsafety.
Council Reluctantly Moves
Forward
Following the public hearings,
Council members remained
visibly frustrated with the
developer’s handling of theADU proposal. They appeareddepleted and defeated, as
if they just went 12 roundswithout boxing gloves.
Several members recalled
the difficult negotiationssurrounding the original 42home
development and thedivisions the project createdwithin Sierra Madre. Council
Member Edward Garcia
acknowledged the strain thecontroversy had placed onlongtime residents and
community relationships.
“Lifelong friendships ended,”
Mayor Lowe said.
Nevertheless, Council
members recognized the legaland financial consequences ofrejecting the agreement.
Council Member Kelly Kriebsexpressed frustration with
how the modifications were
introduced.
“Not only does it feel like a baitand switch, not only because
of the history of negotiationswith the previous developer,
but as I highlighted in myquestions, the way that it waspresented was certainly notin a transparent, upfront wayto slide in plans in a normaldevelopment process,” she
said.
Council Member Robert
Parkhurst was equally critical.
“I’m lost for words,” Parkhurstsaid. “I think that the words
‘bait and switch’ are really
accurate. I think dishonest is
another word for it. But it’s
what we’re faced with, and I
think we’re trying to get, atleast get something out of thepublic benefit agreement.”
Mayor Pro Tem Gene Goss, whoinitially expressed reluctance,
ultimately indicated supportfor the agreement, citing Citystaff’s extensive work and the
potential consequences of
further delays.
But he minced no words about
his frustration.
“I’m just pissed. That’s all Ican say, I’m pissed off,” Gossstated.
“We worked closely with [NewUrban West], and we took a lot
of arrows for that, but we reallydid it because we believed that
what we were doing was goodfor the city,” he said.
“This is not the way a smallcommunity like this can begoverned. I mean, I think thisleaves a bad taste in everybody’smouth,” Goss said.
Council moved to approveResolution No. 26-104,
amended to incorporatethe casita size and setback
restrictions. Mayor Lowe
seconded the motion, and
Council proceeded to a vote.
Council then considered
Resolution No. 26-105,
addressing architectural
modifications for the attached
ADUs, and introduced a
motion to approve it.
The November 10 proceedingshighlighted the increasinglydifficult balance between local
development expectations andCalifornia housing laws thatlimit municipal discretion.
For neighboring residents,
concerns persist about wildfireevacuation, construction
impacts, and the potentialincrease in population.
For City officials, the
compromise offered an
opportunity to secure
financial benefits, affordabilityrequirements, and additional
development restrictions whilenavigating state laws that could
allow many of the same unitswithout those concessions.
Despite the negotiations andreluctant movement toward
approval, the controversysurrounding The Meadows
appears far from over.
The saga continues.
Mountain Views News 80 W Sierra Madre Blvd. No. 327 Sierra Madre, Ca. 91024 Office: 626.355.2737 Fax: 626.609.3285
Email: editor@mtnviewsnews.com Website: www.mtnviewsnews.com
|